Ok well i know this is a super old one and i know you probably dont care much now but i have a good idea for this pic and will upload it when i finish making it. I just have to get through the comments about how im replying to a very old post lol.
It doesn't matter if you use Fraps. Save replay by pressing 2 in the game, then go to replay, and press pause, and do whatever you want. Take the text of with SHIFT+F. Use AA, AF, take .PNG screenshots with Fraps, or otherwise the screen will suck.
Otherwise if the screen shot is not in very good quality, most people don't want to bother to edit it.