Well I certainly haven't seen it before, and if there's no evidence of it being posted before, then JJ72 will remain the winner.

Quote from JJ72 :

lets just say it's impossible.

I have the full PSD plus the original screen.

and I almost never ever do screen edits on my spare time, except for the competition.

Can you show the original?

here you go.

it's a bmp from fraps so it's too big for attachment, i dunno if you can still see the timestamp, it's created on 5/9, 22:15, and the file name say so as well.

http://www.sendspace.com/file/xihiwj