Hard to call a laptop at that price range a "gaming" laptop,I bought mine 2 years ago for 700€ used (that model new close to 1000€) and it's still not really a gaming laptop. I mean,I can still run games like GTA4 on quite high settings on FullHD resoluton,it still lacks the power to run for example Asetto Corsa on decent settings (where 2.5GHz i5 CPU as bottleneck suspected).
That said,I would vote for the first ACER,just because of that GPU,allthough CPU seems like could be a bit weaker part of it,which is still something you can easily upgrade if you're ready to spend extra money later. Then again - I'm no IT specialist,could be that I'm not the best opinion sharer... :P